Orr was a part of the most dominant era in Warrior softball history, winning 128 games over two seasons while making back-to-back national tournament appearances in 2000 and 2001 under head coach Jeff Kelley. Orr's 2001 season ranks as one of the most remarkable in program history, a year that saw the Warriors win a program record 66 games.

As a sophomore in 2001, Orr led the team in on-base percentage, hits, runs, stolen bases, walks, and triples on her way to earning National Junior College Athletic Association (NJCAA) and National Fastpitch Coaches Association (NFCA) First-Team All-American honors. Orr was named team Co-MVP while earning NJCAA Region XI First-Team honors for the second consecutive season.

Following Orr's Indian Hills career, the outfielder moved on to Morehead State University where she left the program as the school's all-time leader in on-base percentage and posted the fourth-highest career batting average. Orr was named First-Team All-Ohio Valley Conference, just the second individual in program history to earn the honor and also earned Academic All-American University Division honors.

A native of Fort Madison, Orr becomes the 16th individual from the Warrior softball program to be inducted into the Indian Hills Hall of Fame.